Long Island serial perv busted for fifth lewd act — but he’s already back on streets

He won’t stop being a jerk! 

A serial perv who keeps groping himself in front of women but then gets cut loose due to New York state’s bail laws was arrested for the same sick crime — and then released again. 

Nicholas Critelli, 20, was arrested yet again this week after a woman identified him from a February incident where he allegedly drove up to her in an AMC movie theater parking lot in Stony Brook just before 10:30 a.m., made eye contact with her, and then began profusely masturbating, police said.

Booking photo of Nicholas Critelli.
Nicholas Critelli, 20, was arrested for pleasuring himself in front of another unsuspecting women just days after he was arrested for a sick, similar spree and set free. Suffolk County DA

“This is now [Critelli’s] fifth criminal case alleging deplorable behavior against women who are simply going about their day,” Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said.

“How many more victims must come forward before State lawmakers realize that our bail laws are completely failing law abiding citizens?” he added. 

The unidentified woman recognized Critelli from news reports of his recent string of arrests for his sick, repeated behavior and went to police to identify him as the culprit in her case, law enforcement officials said. 

Critelli had previously targeted two women in Sayville store parking lots in June. 

He was released on misdemeanor public-lewdness charges, then allegedly struck twice more this month in Walmart and Target lots in Centereach and Commack, authorities said.

He was arrested a second time and again cut loose but this time on supervised release.

Critelli is now back on the streets after his third arrest, officials said Tuesday.

“Case after case shows the same pattern: My office is not allowed to ask for bail despite the seriousness of the alleged crimes and the documented repeated behavior,” Tierney said, calling bail reform a failure.

Investigators believe there could be even more victims and are urging anyone with information to call Suffolk police. 

Critelli, who is being repped by the Legal Aid Society of Suffolk County, has pleaded not guilty to all charges and is due back in court Nov. 4.

Related Posts

“SHE WAS ONLY 18”: Tessa Majors’ Convicted Attacker Walks Free Years Early — Despite a Troubling History of Viol@nce Behind Bars

“SHE WAS ONLY 18”: Tessa Majors’ Convicted Attacker Walks Free Years Early — Despite a Troubling History of Viol@nce Behind Bars
NEW YORK, November 22, 2026 — Nearly seven years after the heartbreakin…

‘OVERWHELMING RELIEF’: JAMES BULGER’S MOTHER DENISE FERGUS SPEAKS OUT AS 𝘬iᩚller JON VENABLES IS DENIED RELEASE AGAIN — A MOTHER’S 33-YEAR FIGHT CONTINUES

‘OVERWHELMING RELIEF’: JAMES BULGER’S MOTHER DENISE FERGUS SPEAKS OUT AS 𝘬iᩚller JON VENABLES IS DENIED RELEASE AGAIN — A MOTHER’S 33-YEAR FIGHT CONTINUES
Denise Fergus has spoken of her overwhelming r…

SHE WAS JUST 20 — BUT HER FLIGHT RECORD TOLD A REMARKABLE STORY: INSIDE NATHALIA FILGUEIRAS’S AVIATION CAREER AND THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE diᩚadℓy LEARJET 60 CR@SH

SHE WAS JUST 20 — BUT HER FLIGHT RECORD TOLD A REMARKABLE STORY: INSIDE NATHALIA FILGUEIRAS’S AVIATION CAREER AND THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE diᩚadℓy LEARJET 60 𝔠r𝘢sh
Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras had acc…

19-YEAR-OLD TALHA MAULED TO DE@TH BY TIGRESS DURING TIKTOK SHOOT — FATHER AND BROTHER WITNESS HORRIFIC αttαᑕk AS POLICE INVESTIGATE ALLEGED COVER-UP

19-YEAR-OLD TALHA MAULED TO dєatᩚh BY TIGRESS DURING TIKTOK SHOOT — FATHER AND BROTHER WITNESS HORRIFIC αttαᑕk AS POLICE INVESTIGATE ALLEGED COVER-UP
A 19-year-old farm worker has died after being atta…

BAYESIAN SUPERYACHT CAPSIZED IN JUST 15 SECONDS: NEW INVESTIGATION REVEALS CREW WERE UNAWARE OF diᩚadℓy SAFETY RISK THAT KILLED SEVEN

BAYESIAN SUPERYACHT CAPSIZED IN JUST 15 SECONDS: NEW INVESTIGATION REVEALS CREW WERE UNAWARE OF diᩚadℓy SAFETY RISK THAT KILLED SEVEN
A devastating new investigation has revealed that the luxury supery…

WHAT WAS BURIED INSIDE THE LEARJET 𝔠r𝘢sh CRATER? Investigators Searched for ᑕriᩚtiᩚcal Wreckage — Then Recovered the Cockpit Voice Recorder

Some pieces of the Learjet’s tail were found almost four miles from where it crashed. Other evidence lay buried inside the crater left in a Palm Beach…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *