LUCY LETBY BOMBSHELL: DOCTOR WHO GAVE KEY EVIDENCE AGAINST NURSE HAD BEEN BARRED FROM TREATING PATIENTS — JURY WAS NEVER TOLD

LUCY LETBY BOMBSHELL: DOCTOR WHO GAVE KEY EVIDENCE AGAINST NURSE HAD BEEN BARRED FROM TREATING PATIENTS — JURY WAS NEVER TOLD

A major new development has emerged in the controversial case of former British neonatal nurse Lucy Letby, after an investigation revealed that a senior medical expert whose testimony played a crucial role in her convictions had been barred from treating patients during the trial.

Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in children’s hormones and insulin, provided important prosecution evidence suggesting that two babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital had been deliberately poisoned with insulin.

However, according to an investigation published by The Guardian on November 18, 2026, Hindmarsh had been excluded from clinical practice by his employer, University College London Hospitals (UCLH), in March 2023 because of concerns about patient safety.

The jury was never informed of the hospital’s decision.

The revelation has raised fresh questions about the evidence presented during Letby’s trial and whether important information about a key prosecution witness should have been disclosed to the defence.

Headshot of child serial killer Lucy Letby.THE DOCTOR WHO HELPED BUILD THE INSULIN POISONING CASE

During the trial, prosecutor Nick Johnson KC introduced Professor Hindmarsh as a leading authority on insulin.

His testimony focused on two babies whose blood test results and medical records, he argued, indicated insulin poisoning.

The prosecution alleged that Letby had deliberately injected insulin into intravenous fluid bags, causing the babies to suffer dangerously low blood sugar levels.

Although there was no direct or forensic evidence identifying anyone who had injected insulin into the bags, Hindmarsh’s medical interpretation became an important part of the prosecution’s argument.

The insulin allegations were particularly significant because the jury returned guilty verdicts on those two attempted murder charges first.

Letby’s solicitor, Mark McDonald, has since described the professor’s testimony as pivotal to the prosecution’s overall case.

He argues that the insulin evidence influenced how jurors viewed the other allegations against his client.

Professor Peter Hindmarsh smiling in a suit and tie.HOSPITAL HAD RAISED SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT THE PROFESSOR

The newly revealed information concerns events that unfolded while Letby’s trial was still underway.

Hindmarsh had already been under investigation by the General Medical Council (GMC), the UK’s medical regulator, over concerns about his professional practice.

In December 2022, UCLH reported concerns about his clinical work to the regulator.

In January 2023, a medical practitioners tribunal imposed restrictions requiring him to work under supervision while the investigation continued.

Then, on March 15, 2023, UCLH informed the GMC that it had excluded him entirely from treating patients.

A medical director at the hospital expressed concern that the professor could pose a risk to children and young people.

Among the issues raised were cases involving advice about insulin and diabetes.

In two cases, Hindmarsh had reportedly advised families that children should stop receiving insulin at home.

One of the children subsequently experienced diabetic ketoacidosis, a potentially life-threatening complication associated with severe insulin deficiency. However, the hospital’s report said it was unclear whether the episode coincided with the alleged advice.

The hospital concluded that it could not safely allow him to continue clinical practice, even under supervision.

WHY WAS THE JURY NOT TOLD?

Perhaps the most significant question concerns why the jury and Letby’s defence team were not informed that the professor had been removed from clinical practice.

Hindmarsh’s professional restrictions were developing while he was still giving evidence in the case.

The defence had been told that he was under investigation by the GMC. However, it was not informed of UCLH’s subsequent decision to bar him from treating patients or the medical tribunal’s April 2023 ruling.

The tribunal decided not to suspend his medical registration, instead requiring direct supervision when treating patients. It also allowed him to continue non-clinical work, including acting as an expert witness.

But UCLH had already excluded him from clinical practice altogether.

According to legal experts cited by The Guardian, expert witnesses have an ongoing duty to disclose information that could undermine their professional credibility or the reliability of their opinions.

This includes relevant disciplinary proceedings and restrictions imposed by professional regulators.

The newly revealed information could therefore become significant in the ongoing review of Letby’s convictions.

LETBY’S LAWYER SAYS THE EVIDENCE WAS THE CORNERSTONE OF THE CASE

Mark McDonald has argued that the insulin allegations were not simply another part of the prosecution’s case.

He believes they were presented to the jury as scientific proof that Letby had deliberately poisoned babies and was capable of committing murder.

He has questioned whether the jury would have assessed Hindmarsh’s evidence differently had it known about the concerns raised by his hospital.

Seven experts have also contributed reports challenging aspects of Hindmarsh’s medical conclusions. They question the interpretation of the blood tests and whether the available evidence supports the prosecution’s theory of insulin poisoning.

These arguments have been submitted in support of Letby’s application to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC).

The CCRC is an independent body responsible for investigating potential miscarriages of justice and can refer cases back to the Court of Appeal when the legal criteria are met.

WHAT HAVE THE AUTHORITIES SAID?

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) told The Guardian that it had met all its disclosure obligations.

The CPS explained that it had not been informed of Hindmarsh’s exclusion from clinical practice or the subsequent tribunal ruling.

A representative for Professor Hindmarsh declined to comment on the questions raised by the investigation.

The GMC investigation never reached a final determination. In November 2024, Hindmarsh voluntarily relinquished his medical registration, bringing the investigation to an end without a final ruling on the allegations.

LUCY LETBY CONTINUES TO MAINTAIN HER INNOCENCE

Letby, now 36, was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2016.

She received 15 whole-life sentences and has consistently maintained that she is innocent.

Her previous attempts to appeal were rejected by the Court of Appeal.

Her legal team is now pursuing a fresh review through the CCRC, relying on new expert reports and questions surrounding the medical evidence presented at trial.

The latest revelation does not automatically overturn her convictions, nor does it establish that the original verdicts were wrong.

But it has brought renewed attention to a central question surrounding the case: Was the jury given all the information it needed to properly assess one of the prosecution’s most important medical witnesses?

For the families of the babies involved, and for everyone following this extraordinary case, the answer to that question remains hugely significant.

The convictions remain in place. But fresh questions about the evidence used to secure them are now demanding attention.

Related Posts

20-YEAR-OLD ILLINOIS ENTREPRENEUR diᩚєs IN JAMAICA AFTER JUMPING INTO WATERFALL TO HELP HIS MOTHER — HE HAD BUILT A $500,000 BUSINESS FROM THE GROUND UP

20-YEAR-OLD ILLINOIS ENTREPRENEUR diᩚєs IN JAMAICA AFTER JUMPING INTO WATERFALL TO HELP HIS MOTHER — HE HAD BUILT A $500,000 BUSINESS FROM THE GROUND UP
A 20-year-old entrepreneur from Illinois has die…

CHILLING SURVEILLANCE FOOTAGE: AN UNKNOWN FIGURE LEAVES ZACHARIAH SCHUCK’S ABANDONED CAR AS SEARCH FOR MISSING FATHER CONTINUES

CHILLING SURVEILLANCE FOOTAGE: AN UNKNOWN FIGURE LEAVES ZACHARIAH SCHUCK’S ABANDONED CAR AS SEARCH FOR MISSING FATHER CONTINUES
A grainy surveillance recording has become one of the most important una…

JAMES BULGER’S MOTHER DENISE FERGUS BREAKS HER SILENCE AFTER JON VENABLES IS DENIED PAROLE — ‘OVERWHELMING RELIEF’ AFTER MORE THAN 30 YEARS OF HEARTBREAK

JAMES BULGER’S MOTHER DENISE FERGUS BREAKS HER SILENCE AFTER JON VENABLES IS DENIED PAROLE — ‘OVERWHELMING RELIEF’ AFTER MORE THAN 30 YEARS OF HEARTBREAK
LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND — More than three decades a…

SHE HAD JUST LOST HER MOTHER — THEN A F@TAL 𝔠r𝘢sh TOOK HER LIFE AT 31: FAMILY PAYS HEARTBREAKING TRIBUTE TO ‘DEEPLY CARING’ CAITLIN WALKER

SHE HAD JUST LOST HER MOTHER — THEN A FATAL 𝔠r𝘢sh TOOK HER LIFE AT 31: FAMILY PAYS HEARTBREAKING TRIBUTE TO ‘DEEPLY CARING’ CAITLIN WALKER
DARLINGTON, ENGLAND — A family already grieving the recent lo…

“333 FEET EVERY SECOND”: CHILLING NEW RECONSTRUCTION REVEALS FINAL MOMENTS OF FLORIDA LEARJET 𝔠r𝘢sh THAT KILLED NINE — INCLUDING TWO YOUNG CHILDREN

“333 FEET EVERY SECOND”: CHILLING NEW RECONSTRUCTION REVEALS FINAL MOMENTS OF FLORIDA LEARJET 𝔠r𝘢sh THAT KILLED NINE — INCLUDING TWO YOUNG CHILDREN
GREENACRES, FLORIDA — November 18, 2026
A chilling r…

20-YEAR-OLD ENTREPRENEUR diᩚєs TRYING TO SAVE HIS MOTHER FROM WATERFALL DURING FAMILY VACATION — HE HAD BUILT A $500,000 BUSINESS

20-YEAR-OLD ENTREPRENEUR diᩚєs TRYING TO SAVE HIS MOTHER FROM WATERFALL DURING FAMILY VACATION — HE HAD BUILT A $500,000 BUSINESS
OCHO RIOS, JAMAICA — A young Illinois entrepreneur lost his life while …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *