‘WE WERE LEFT TO SAVE OURSELVES’: MOTHER WHO HELD BABY ABOVE WAVES AS BAYESIAN SUPERYACHT SANK ACCUSES CREW OF ‘RECKLESS’ FAILURES
Charlotte Golunski, the mother who desperately held her one-year-old daughter above the water as the Bayesian superyacht sank off Sicily, has spoken out with her partner about the terrifying final moments aboard the vessel. The couple allege that the crew failed to sound an alarm, provide adequate safety instructions or organize an evacuation in time, leaving their family to fight for survival in the darkness.
More than two years after one of the Mediterranean’s most devastating maritime disasters, new allegations have emerged from one of the families who survived.
Charlotte Golunski, now 37, and her partner, James Emslie, have described what they say happened aboard the 184-foot Bayesian superyacht during the night it sank off the coast of Sicily on August 19, 2024.
Their account paints a deeply disturbing picture of confusion, inadequate emergency preparation and a desperate struggle to escape the sinking vessel.
Charlotte became known around the world after surviving the disaster while holding her one-year-old daughter above the waves.
Now, through legal documents filed in London’s High Court, the couple are accusing the yacht’s crew and management of serious failures that they believe contributed to the catastrophe.
The allegations were made in formal legal paperwork signed by both parents under a statement of truth.
A MOTHER’S DESPERATE FIGHT TO KEEP HER BABY ABOVE WATER
The Bayesian was anchored near Porticello, Sicily, when a violent storm struck in the early hours of August 19, 2024.
On board were 22 people, including 12 passengers and 10 crew members.
Among the passengers were British technology entrepreneur Mike Lynch, his family, friends and business associates.
As the yacht began to capsize, passengers were thrown into a terrifying situation.
Charlotte found herself fighting to keep her young daughter alive in the dark, violent water.
At one point, she briefly lost sight of her child beneath the waves before managing to find and embrace her again.
She later described holding the little girl above the water with all her strength, stretching her arms upward to prevent her from drowning.
“It was all dark. In the water I couldn’t keep my eyes open. I screamed for help but all I could hear around me was the screams of others,” she recalled.
Her partner was also caught in the terrifying struggle as the family attempted to survive.
The mother and child eventually survived after a life raft inflated and provided a way out of the water.
Their survival became one of the most widely shared stories from the disaster.
But Charlotte and James now say the experience was made even more frightening by what they describe as a lack of preparation and assistance from the crew.
‘NO ALARM WAS SOUNDED’ — THE COUPLE’S SERIOUS ALLEGATIONS
In their legal defence, Charlotte and James identify 18 alleged failures by the yacht’s crew.
One of their most serious accusations is that no emergency alarm was sounded to warn passengers that the vessel was in danger.
They also claim they were never adequately shown how to access or use life jackets.
The couple further allege that no appropriate safety briefing had been provided regarding their one-year-old daughter.
According to their legal documents, the captain had instructed crew members to wake him if the wind exceeded 20 knots or if the yacht’s anchor began dragging.
However, the couple allege that the instruction was not followed promptly.
They also claim that the vessel was not positioned in a safe location despite the approaching storm and that an adequate overnight watch was not maintained.
The allegations extend to emergency lighting, distress signals and the deployment of life rafts.
Charlotte and James say the crew failed to organize passengers into designated emergency gathering points or issue an evacuation order until it was too late.
Their legal submission describes the family as having been left to scramble for safety with very limited assistance from the captain and crew.
These are allegations made in ongoing legal proceedings and have not all been established by a court.
QUESTIONS OVER THE CAPTAIN AND THE YACHT’S PREPARATION
The couple have also raised questions about the captain’s actions as the storm approached.
Their legal documents allege that the captain was asleep while dangerous weather conditions were developing and that the yacht’s emergency response was delayed.
They argue that the vessel should have been moved to a safer position before the storm intensified.
The Bayesian was a luxury sailing yacht featuring an enormous 72-metre mast, one of the most distinctive features of the vessel.
Charlotte’s legal defence argues that the yacht’s design, specifications and construction were unsuitable for its intended use under the conditions it encountered.
The couple believe the yacht’s stability and safety arrangements should have been examined more carefully.
They also argue that the owners and those responsible for operating the vessel should have recognized the risks.
SEVEN PEOPLE DIED IN THE BAYESIAN DISASTER
The sinking claimed seven lives.
Among those killed were Mike Lynch, the British technology entrepreneur often described as the country’s answer to Bill Gates, and his 18-year-old daughter Hannah.
Other victims included:
- Jonathan Bloomer, chairman of Morgan Stanley International.
- His wife, Judy Bloomer.
- Chris Morvillo, a prominent American lawyer.
- His wife, Neda Morvillo.
- Recaldo Thomas, the yacht’s chef.
Mike Lynch’s wife, Angela Bacares, survived the disaster.
The tᩚraɢedy shocked the international business and maritime communities, particularly because the yacht was considered a sophisticated luxury sailing vessel.
The Bayesian was eventually recovered from the seabed in a major salvage operation in June 2025.
A NEW INVESTIGATION REPORT POINTS TOWARD CREW FAILURES
The latest developments have added another significant dimension to the controversy.
On November 12–13, 2026, reports from Italy revealed preliminary findings from experts appointed by prosecutors investigating the disaster.
According to the reported findings, investigators believe the yacht did not sink because of a fundamental design defect.
Instead, the experts reportedly concluded that the conduct of the crew played a decisive role.
One major issue was the position of the yacht’s retractable keel, which was not fully lowered when the storm struck.
The keel is an important part of a sailing yacht’s stability system. When fully extended, it helps counterbalance the forces acting on the vessel.
Investigators believe that the raised position reduced the yacht’s ability to resist the powerful gusts of wind.
The experts also reportedly assessed that the weather conditions, although dangerous, were not beyond what the vessel should have been able to withstand if appropriate precautions had been taken.
Their preliminary conclusions reportedly place particular scrutiny on three crew members:
- Captain James Cutfield.
- Chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton.
- Deckhand Matthew Griffiths, who was on watch during the night of the disaster.
The final technical report was expected to be submitted by the end of November 2026, with prosecutors anticipating further investigative developments in December.
These findings remain part of the ongoing investigation rather than a final criminal court judgment.
THE LEGAL BATTLE OVER COMPENSATION
Charlotte and James are also involved in a separate legal dispute concerning compensation for the injuries and trauma they suffered.
The company that owned the Bayesian, Revtom Limited, is seeking to limit its financial liability through a legal process based on longstanding maritime law.
The company has named the couple and their young daughter among the defendants in its limitation-of-liability proceedings.
The family is challenging that position.
Under maritime law, a shipowner may lose the right to limit compensation if a court establishes that the loss resulted from conduct involving the relevant level of personal fault or recklessness.
Charlotte’s legal team argues that the circumstances surrounding the disaster went far beyond an ordinary accident.
The couple have also sent a formal letter of claim to yacht management company Camper & Nicholsons, which hired the crew.
They intend to pursue a personal injury claim and say they have not received all the technical, stability and crew records they have requested.
The dispute could become a significant part of the wider legal aftermath of the Bayesian disaster.
A MOTHER WHO SURVIVED NOW WANTS ANSWERS
For Charlotte Golunski, the legal battle is about more than financial compensation.
She survived a night in which she feared she would lose her daughter in the sea.
Her family made it through the disaster, but seven other people never returned home.
The questions raised by her account are now part of a much wider examination of what happened aboard the Bayesian.
Were passengers properly warned? Were emergency procedures followed? Could the yacht have been positioned more safely? And could the tᩚraɢedy have been prevented?
As investigators continue their work and the legal proceedings develop, the answers may finally emerge.
For now, Charlotte’s account offers a deeply personal perspective on a disaster that claimed seven lives and left survivors with memories they will carry for the rest of their lives.
She held her baby above the waves that night and survived.
Now, she and her partner are determined to have their allegations heard and to find out exactly what happened aboard the Bayesian.