“PRESERVED FOREVER”: CHILLING EVIDENCE FROM CHRISTA PIKE’S 1995 MURDER OF COLLEEN SLEMMER REMAINS LOCKED INSIDE TENNESSEE VAULT — PINK SWEATER, BLOODY GAG AND SKULL FRAGMENT AMONG ITEMS KEPT FOR DECADES
KNOXVILLE, TENNESSEE — November 18, 2026
More than 30 years after one of Tennessee’s most notorious murders, the physical evidence from the brutal 𝘬iᩚlling of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer remains locked inside a government storage vault in Knox County.
The collection includes a pink sweater bearing what appears to be a shoe print, a bloodstained cloth gag with strands of the victim’s hair still knotted in it, a small meat cleaver, matching pentagram necklaces and a black leather jacket that once concealed a fragment of Slemmer’s skull.
The items were presented as evidence during the trial of Christa Pike, who was convicted of torturing and murdering Slemmer in January 1995.
Now, in a rare look inside the county’s evidence storage system, officials have explained why these disturbing objects will never be discarded — regardless of whether Pike eventually diᩚєs in prison or faces another exє𝔠uti☉n attempt.
INSIDE THE LOCKED BASEMENT VAULT
Knox County Criminal Court Clerk Mike Hammond recently discussed the collection of evidence retained from Pike’s capital murder case.
According to Hammond, Tennessee’s evidence-retention requirements for capital cases mean the materials must be preserved indefinitely.
“In a capital case like Christa Pike’s, we will never get rid of it because the law says in those instances you will keep that forever, even if the person is executed,” Hammond explained.
The evidence is stored in a special secured area beneath the government building.
Among the most striking objects is Slemmer’s pink sweater, which reportedly still bears a visible shoe imprint on its back.
Other clothing items include a green jacket, dirty sneakers and jeans showing signs of damage and mud.
Investigators also preserved a cloth gag that had been forced into Slemmer’s mouth during the αttαᑕk. Strands of her hair reportedly remain tangled in the fabric.
A small meat cleaver connected to the murder is another part of the collection, still wrapped in the brown paper used to store it decades ago.
The evidence also includes matching pentagram necklaces associated with Pike and her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp.
Perhaps most disturbing is the black leather jacket in which Pike reportedly concealed a fragment of Slemmer’s skull after the 𝘬iᩚlling.
These are not simply forgotten objects from an old criminal case. They remain part of the permanent legal record of a murder that shocked Knoxville.
THE 1995 MURDER THAT SHOCKED TENNESSEE
The 𝘬iᩚlling took place in January 1995, when Pike was 18 years old.
Slemmer, 19, was a fellow student at the Knoxville Job Corps Center.
According to the prosecution’s case, Pike and her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp, lured Slemmer away from the center to an area near the University of Tennessee’s agricultural campus and Tyson Park.
What followed was a prolonged and extraordinarily violent αttαᑕk.
Slemmer was tortured, beaten and stabbed. Prosecutors described how the attackers used various weapons during the assault, which ultimately left the young woman dead.
Pike was later convicted of first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder and other related offenses.
Shipp was also convicted in connection with the crime and received a lengthy prison sentence.
The brutality of the 𝘬iᩚlling and the evidence presented at trial made the case one of Tennessee’s most widely remembered capital murder prosecutions.
WHY THE PENTAGRAM NECKLACES BECAME PART OF THE CASE
The matching pentagram necklaces became particularly recognizable pieces of evidence during the investigation and trial.
Pike and Shipp were associated with the jewelry, which prosecutors presented as part of the physical evidence connecting the defendants to the case.
The necklaces, along with the clothing, weapons and other recovered materials, helped preserve a detailed record of the crime.
The evidence was examined and presented to jurors during the proceedings that ultimately resulted in Pike’s dєatᩚh sentence.
More than three decades later, the items remain in government custody.
CHRISTA PIKE SURVIVED TENNESSEE’S SEPTEMBER 30 exє𝔠uti☉n ATTEMPT
While the old murder evidence remains preserved in Knoxville, Pike’s own legal situation has taken an extraordinary turn.
On September 30, 2026, Tennessee attempted to execute the 50-year-old inmate by lєthaℓ inje𝔠ti☉n at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville.
The exє𝔠uti☉n attempt failed.
According to court filings and accounts from her attorneys, prison officials administered two doses of pentobarbital, but Pike remained alive.
Her lawyers subsequently described serious problems with the intravenous lines used during the procedure.
Attorney Randy Spivey, who witnessed the attempted exє𝔠uti☉n, later alleged that the exє𝔠uti☉n team struggled to establish functioning IV access and used approximately 10 needles.
Pike was eventually transported to a hospital for emergency medical treatment.
She remained on life support for several days before regaining consciousness in October.
Her attorneys have subsequently described significant medical complications, including injuries to her arms, cognitive difficulties and other ongoing health problems.
The state has maintained that it followed its established exє𝔠uti☉n protocol, while an independent review was initiated following the failed attempt.
TENNESSEE NOW WANTS TO BLOCK TESTING OF THE LEFTOVER exє𝔠uti☉n DRUGS
The legal battle surrounding Pike’s failed exє𝔠uti☉n has continued into November.
Her attorneys want access to the remaining pentobarbital used during the September 30 procedure so independent experts can examine and test the drug.
They argue that testing could help determine whether the medication was improperly stored, transported, prepared or administered.
However, Tennessee officials are seeking to prevent Pike’s legal team from inspecting or testing the remaining drug.
In a court filing, Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti argued that allowing access to the drug vials and their labels could expose the state’s confidential supplier.
A Tennessee Department of Correction employee also warned that revealing the supplier’s identity could jeopardize the state’s ability to obtain lєthaℓ-inje𝔠ti☉n drugs in the future.
The dispute has placed two competing concerns before the court: Pike’s legal team’s demand to investigate what went wrong during the exє𝔠uti☉n attempt and the state’s position that supplier confidentiality must be protected.
A judge had previously ordered the preservation of evidence connected to the failed exє𝔠uti☉n, including drugs, medical equipment, records and recordings.
The latest dispute concerns whether Pike’s attorneys should be permitted to examine and test the remaining medication.
TWO SEPARATE COLLECTIONS OF EVIDENCE — ONE CASE THAT CONTINUES TO MAKE HISTORY
The evidence vault in Knox County and the exє𝔠uti☉n-related evidence in Nashville represent two separate chapters of the same criminal case.
One preserves the physical objects used to establish Pike’s guilt in the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer.
The other may help determine why Tennessee’s attempt to carry out Pike’s exє𝔠uti☉n failed more than three decades later.
For Slemmer’s family, the permanent preservation of the original evidence ensures that the physical record of her 𝘬iᩚlling will not disappear.
For Pike, the failed exє𝔠uti☉n has opened a new and uncertain legal chapter.
As of November 18, 2026, she remains under a dєatᩚh sentence, while litigation over the failed exє𝔠uti☉n and access to the remaining drugs continues.
And deep inside a locked government vault in Knoxville, the pink sweater, the necklaces, the meat cleaver and the other objects connected to the 1995 murder remain exactly where officials say they must stay.
More than 30 years have passed since Colleen Slemmer was m𝑢rdєred. The evidence has never disappeared — and under Tennessee’s capital-case retention requirements, it may remain preserved long after the legal battle surrounding Christa Pike reaches its final chapter.