“WE WERE LEFT TO SAVE OURSELVES”: MOTHER WHO HELD HER BABY ABOVE THE WAVES AS BAYESIAN SUPERYACHT SANK ACCUSES CREW OF “RECKLESS” FAILURES
A mother who desperately held her one-year-old daughter above the waves as a luxury superyacht sank off the coast of Sicily has spoken out about the terrifying moments her family fought to survive.
Charlotte Golunski, 37, and her partner, James Emslie, survived the August 2024 disaster aboard the Bayesian, which claimed seven lives, including British technology billionaire Mike Lynch and his 18-year-old daughter, Hannah.
Now, in newly reported legal claims, the couple have accused the yacht’s crew of serious failures before and during the sinking, alleging that they were left to scramble for their own safety as the vessel went down.
Their allegations include claims that passengers were not properly briefed on emergency procedures, no adequate alarm was sounded and the crew failed to provide sufficient assistance when the emergency unfolded.
The accusations form part of an ongoing legal dispute and have not yet been established as findings of a court.
A MOTHER’S DESPERATE FIGHT TO SAVE HER BABY
The Bayesian sank in the early hours of August 19, 2024, during severe weather off the coast of Porticello, near Palermo, Sicily.
As the yacht capsized, passengers and crew were thrown into a terrifying struggle for survival in the darkness.
Charlotte later described the desperate effort to keep her young daughter above the water.
She held the little girl high in her arms, using all her strength to stop her from drowning as powerful waves surrounded them.
At one point, she briefly lost hold of her daughter in the water before managing to grab her again.
The family eventually reached safety after a life raft inflated.
For Charlotte and James, surviving the disaster came at an unimaginable emotional cost, particularly as seven people aboard the vessel did not make it out alive.
COUPLE ACCUSE CREW OF RECKLESS FAILURES
In legal documents reported by The Sun, Charlotte and James set out a series of alleged failures by the yacht’s crew.
They claim passengers were not given an adequate safety briefing and were not properly shown how to use life jackets.
They also allege that no effective alarm was sounded in time, emergency systems did not function properly and warnings to passengers came too late.
The couple further claim that the crew failed to provide adequate assistance during the evacuation, leaving them to find a way to safety themselves.
Their legal allegations reportedly identify 18 areas of concern involving the yacht’s operation, safety procedures and emergency response.
The claims paint a deeply troubling picture of the moments before and during the disaster. However, they remain allegations within the legal proceedings, and the crew’s responsibility has not been finally determined by a court.
SEVEN PEOPLE LOST THEIR LIVES
The sinking killed seven of the 22 people aboard the Bayesian.
Among the victims were Mike Lynch and his daughter Hannah, along with Morgan Stanley International chairman Jonathan Bloomer and his wife Judy.
Lynch’s lawyer, Chris Morvillo, and his wife Neda also died, as did the yacht’s chef, Recaldo Thomas.
Fifteen people survived, including Lynch’s wife, Angela Bacares.
The tᩚraɢedy shocked the international business community and raised serious questions about how such a large luxury sailing yacht could sink so quickly.
QUESTIONS OVER THE YACHT’S SAFETY AND THE CREW’S RESPONSE
The latest legal claims come amid continuing investigations into the circumstances surrounding the sinking.
Italian investigators have examined the crew’s actions, the weather conditions and the yacht’s safety systems.
A report published in April 2026 indicated that investigators believed the weather alone was not sufficient to explain the disaster. The reported findings pointed instead to the crew’s handling of the conditions and the failure to activate certain safety measures correctly.
Prosecutors have been investigating possible offences involving negligent shipwreck and multiple counts of manslaughter in connection with the disaster.
The yacht’s design and stability have also become subjects of dispute, with different parties presenting competing explanations for why the vessel sank.
A LEGAL BATTLE OVER COMPENSATION
The survivors’ allegations are also connected to a wider legal dispute over compensation.
The company associated with the yacht’s ownership, Revtom Limited, is seeking to limit its financial liability for claims arising from the disaster.
Charlotte and James argue that the alleged conduct surrounding the sinking should prevent the company from benefiting from such a limitation.
Whether that argument succeeds will depend on the legal proceedings and the evidence considered by the court.
The dispute means that the tᩚraɢedy is not only about establishing what happened on the night the Bayesian sank, but also about determining who should be held legally responsible.
TWO YEARS LATER, QUESTIONS REMAIN
For Charlotte and James, the memories of that night are inseparable from the moment they fought to keep their baby alive.
They survived, but seven other people lost their lives, leaving families facing an irreversible loss.
Their latest allegations have renewed scrutiny of the yacht’s emergency procedures and the decisions made by those responsible for the vessel.
As the legal battle continues, the central questions remain: Were passengers adequately prepared for an emergency? Did the crew respond quickly enough? And could more lives have been saved?
For the families of those who died, and for the survivors who still carry the memories of that terrifying night, the answers matter enormously.