Nutty Florida man sends letter filled with peanut butter to ex-wife’s allergic friend he blamed for couple’s divorce: cops

He’s nuts!

A warped Florida man stuffed a card full of peanut butter and mailed it to a friend of his ex-wife with a severe peanut allergy whom he blamed for the couple’s breakup, police said. 

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, was arrested Friday for allegedly sending the letter, which arrived at the nut-𝘴єn𝘴iᩚtiᩚvє woman’s home on Aug. 14, 2025.

Mugshot of an older man with graying hair and a goatee.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare, Jr., 68, allegedly sent the peanut-y epistle that arrived at the nut-𝘴єn𝘴iᩚtiᩚvє woman’s home on Aug. 14, the Plantation Police Department said, according to Local 10.  Broward County Sheriff’s Office

The woman told the Plantation Police Department she found the greasy blue envelope in her mailbox, before opening it and finding the letter contained the potentially diᩚadℓy allergen, according to an arrest report. 

A spoonful of creamy peanut butter scooped from a glass jar, with whole peanuts in the background.

The peanut-allergic woman told cops that she found a greasy blue envelope in her mailbox, before opening it and finding the letter contained the potentially diᩚadℓy allergen, according to an arrest report.  Africa Studio – stock.adobe.com

Cops said the woman rushed inside to clean the sticky substance off her hands, experiencing tingling and developing hives on both her arms for nearly six hours. 

Investigators were able to trace the envelope’s two stamps back to a USPS kiosk in Davie on Aug. 8 and discovered they’d been purchased by a credit card in Cancellare’s name, cops said. 

The woman told police that Cancellare was previously married to her friend, and that the three had known each other for nearly 20 years, the arrest report states. 

The victim told cops that Cancellare would be aware of her allergy since she had to make an effort to avoid exposure to peanuts in food.

A Plantation police vehicle parked at night with its blue emergency lights flashing.

Cancellare would have known about his ex-wife’s friend’s nut allergy, as she had to make an effort to avoid exposure to peanuts in food due to the severity of her allergy, the victim told cops.  Plantation Police Department

The three last spoke in July 2022, where the woman witnessed a division of property during the couple’s divorce, a hostile parting that Cancellare blamed the friend for, according to the report. 

Police alleged that Cancellare sent the peanut card on purpose after another acquaintance of the couple told police that Cancellare was aware of the woman’s peanut allergy.

The other companion also claimed Cancellare previously said he wanted to hurt the woman, the arrest report states. 

Cancellare was charged with culpable negligence exposing another person to harm and aggravated battery with a diᩚadℓy w𝔢𝔞𝔭𝔬η, police said. 

Cancellare is being held at the Broward Sheriff’s Office North Broward Bureau jail, with a bond set at $20,000. 

Related Posts

$1 MILLION LAWSUIT FILED AFTER TANKER SMASHES INTO CRUISE SHIP, LEAVING 197 PEOPLE FIGHTING FOR SURVIVAL IN THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER

$1 MILLION LAWSUIT FILED AFTER TANKER SMASHES INTO CRUISE SHIP, LEAVING 197 PEOPLE FIGHTING FOR SURVIVAL IN THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER
NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA — A terrifying collision between a massive oil …

HEARTBREAKING: EIGHT PEOPLE, INCLUDING TWO CHILDREN, KI//ED IN DEVASTATING BROOKLYN BUILDING COLLAPSE

HEARTBREAKING: EIGHT PEOPLE, INCLUDING TWO CHILDREN, KILLED IN DEVASTATING BROOKLYN BUILDING COLLAPSE
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK — Eight people, including two young children, have been identified as the victi…

11-MONTH-OLD KOAH SHARP IS FINALLY HOME AFTER MIRACULOUS RESCUE — FATHER DENIED BOND

11-MONTH-OLD KOAH SHARP IS FINALLY HOME AFTER MIRACULOUS RESCUE — FATHER DENIED BOND
After surviving an ordeal that has shocked people across the country, 11-month-old Koah Sharp has been released fro…

THE LEARJET SWITCHED RADIO FREQUENCIES BEFORE THE 𝔠r𝘢sh — What Could the New Controller See?

The Bahamas-bound Learjet had already received a warning about weather along its route. Later, the crew switched radio frequencies and checked in with another air traffic controller….

MYSTERY DEEPENS AFTER MISSOURI COUPLE FOUND DEAD IN WOODS — AUTOPSIES REVEAL NO OBVIOUS TRAUMA AS TOXICOLOGY RESULTS REMAIN PENDING

MYSTERY DEEPENS AFTER MISSOURI COUPLE FOUND DEAD IN WOODS — AUTOPSIES REVEAL NO OBVIOUS TRAUMA AS TOXICOLOGY RESULTS REMAIN PENDING
Authorities in Missouri are still searching for answers after an eld…

MIRACLE BABY KOAH SHARP, 11 MONTHS OLD, IS FINALLY HOME AFTER BEING FOUND BURIED ALIVE — FATHER DENIED BOND

MIRACLE BABY KOAH SHARP, 11 MONTHS OLD, IS FINALLY HOME AFTER BEING FOUND BURIED ALIVE — FATHER DENIED BOND
An 11-month-old baby boy who survived an unimaginable ordeal is finally home with his family…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *