David Smith arrived with a photograph of his sons pinned to his jacket. Thirty-two years after Michael and Alex were killed, their father was once again asking a South Carolina parole board to keep their mother in prison.
Susan Smith, now 55, appeared by video on November 19, 2026, seeking release for the second time. The board unanimously denied her request. She had also been denied parole in 2024.
For David, the passing decades had done little to soften the loss.
“It’s been 32 years since I buried Michael and Alex,” he told the board. He said the grief still felt as immediate as yesterday. He urged members to remember that his sons had been deliberately denied the chance to grow up. ArcaMax Publishing

She told the board she had changed
Speaking from Leath Correctional Institution, Susan apologized for 𝘬iᩚlling her children and for the pain she caused their father. She acknowledged the milestones David never got to share with them, including watching them learn to ride bicycles and go to school.
Her attorney and supporters described a woman whose mєntal health had improved and who had helped other inmates. Her legal team asked the board to consider the treatment she had received and the person they said she had become during her incarceration.
The board also heard that she had received no disciplinary infractions since her previous parole hearing. David remained firmly opposed to her release. His wife, Tiffany, asked why Susan should have the opportunity to walk free when Michael and Alex had never been given the opportunity to live.

For nine days, she claimed someone had taken the boys
On October 25, 1994, Susan let her car roll into John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina. Three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex were still buckled into their car seats.
She then falsely told authorities that a Black man had carjacked her and driven away with the children. For nine days, she made public appeals for their return as investigators searched. She eventually confessed.
At her trial, prosecutors argued that she wanted to pursue a relationship with a man who did not want children. Her defense pointed to her mєntal health struggles. A jury convicted her in 1995 and chose a life sentence instead of the dєatᩚh penalty prosecutors sought.

The decision keeps her in prison — with another hearing possible
The law governing Susan’s sentence allowed her to seek parole after 30 years and apply again every two years if denied. Her next opportunity is in 2028. apnews.com
Former prosecutor Tommy Pope told the board he wanted to pursue legislation extending the interval between hearings to three to five years. For David and his family, each new application means returning to argue against her release.
After hearing testimony from both sides, the board reached its unanimous decision in less than two minutes, according to The State. Board chair Mollie DuPriest Taylor acknowledged what those repeated hearings required of David.
“We are so sorry you have to endure this every two years,” she told him.