Husband who claimed wife died in freak accident at home arrested after twisted internet search history revealed

A cheating husband who claimed his wife died in a freak accident at their Wisconsin home two years ago has been charged with her dєatᩚh after investigators discovered his disturbing internet search history.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was arrested Tuesday for planning and causing the dєatᩚh of his wife and mother of his son, Erica Carpenter, 40 — who he claimed hit her head when he slipped while carrying her up their basement stairs in October 2024.

The man had said his wife collapsed while she was doing laundry, according to a criminal complaint obtained by TMJ4.

Benjamin Carpenter faces a first-degree intentional homicide charge in connection with the October 2024 death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, in West Allis, Wis.

Benjamin Carpenter faces a first-degree intentional homicide charge in connection with the October 2024 dєatᩚh of his wife, Erica Carpenter, in West Allis, Wis. Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office

Police seized Benjamin’s phone during the investigation, which revealed that Erica had confronted him weeks before her dєatᩚh about messing with her water, texting him “There’s been powdery s–t in it at least twice now.”

He told her that she had mistakenly been drinking his water, which had been mixed with “liquid IV.”

The same day as that conversation, he searched for “losing someone,” “watching someone you love die” and “dєatᩚh of a Loved One: Quotes, Poems, and Resources…” according to the charging documents.

Erica had doxylamine, a sleeping medication, and hydrocodone, a prescription pain medication, in her system when she died, according to a toxicology report.

She had texted her husband weeks before her dєatᩚh asking him to research a sleep aid for them.

Police responded to a request for a welfare check at the couple’s home in West Allis, a Milwaukee suburb, on Oct. 13, 2024.

Benjamin Carpenter faces a first-degree intentional homicide charge in the October 2024 death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, in West Allis.

Benjamin Carpenter is accused of 𝘬iᩚlling his wife, Erica Carpenter, two years ago. Erica Carpenter / Facebook

There, they found Erica unconscious as Benjamin spun an elaborate tale as to what happened.

He said she fainted and hit her head while they were doing laundry together in the basement — which was loud enough that it awoke their sleeping son upstairs, Law and Crime reported.

The son told police that on the night of his mother’s alleged fatal fall, he heard a “thud” after hearing a “scream.” 

Benjamin said that as he carried his wife up the stairs, he slipped, causing them both to fall down. Erica hit her head on a cinder block wall at the bottom of the stairs, he said. 

She was rushed to a local hospital where she died from her injuries.

Erica Carpenter's cause of death was ultimately undetermined by the medical examiner's office.

Erica Carpenter’s cause of dєatᩚh was ultimately undetermined by the medical examiner’s office. Erica Carpenter / Facebook

An official cause of dєatᩚh was undetermined, but the medical examiner’s office said her dєatᩚh may have been the result of asphyxia and indicated a blunt force neck injury, according to Fox 6 Now.

Benjamin was questioned by police about his background as a jiu-jitsu black belt and the choke submission move, according to the complaint.

He admitted to investigators that he was having an affair with another woman, identified in court documents only as AMV, and said he had planned to ask Erica for a divorce the same weekend that she died.

Benjamin had met AMV at work months earlier — but those close to the suspected 𝘬iᩚller were concerned about how easily and fast he seemed to move on after his wife’s dєatᩚh.

Benjamin’s son told police he was introduced to his dad’s new girlfriend just one day after his mother died and that she moved in around December 2024 or January 2025.

About a month after his mother’s dєatᩚh, Benjamin took down the photos of Erica in the kitchen — which he said confused and upset him.

Just three days after Erica’s funeral, Benjamin purchased a diamond bracelet from Jared Jewelers for $3,754, according to financial documents reviewed by police. 

Two days after buying the bracelet, he called his insurance and claimed he couldn’t pay for his mortgage and vehicle due to his wife’s funeral expenses. 

He also repeatedly called his insurance company asking when he would receive his late wife’s $300,000 insurance policy — even though he’d told cops he didn’t even know she had life insurance.

Meanwhile, he also raised $22,000 through a GoFundMe and another $6,000 from a local pub crawl.

Benjamin is charged with first-degree intentional homicide.

He made his initial court appearance on Wednesday, where a judge set his cash bond at $500,000. He is scheduled to appear again for his preliminary hearing on Dec. 8.

Related Posts

Husband almost killed celiac wife by rubbing hands on burrito, touching her face: cops

Now he’s taking the “wrap.”

A raging husband in Washington state allegedly almost killed his celiac disease-inflicted wife by rubbing his hands on a burrito and wiping them on her face as they bicker…

TRAGIC DISCOVERY IN SEARCH FOR MISSING BRIDE-TO-BE, 29: BODY FOUND AFTER EREN WRIGHT VANISHED FROM HOME — CCTV FOOTAGE HELPED TRACE HER FINAL MOVEMENTS

TRAGIC DISCOVERY IN SEARCH FOR MISSING BRIDE-TO-BE, 29: BODY FOUND AFTER EREN WRIGHT VANISHED FROM HOME — CCTV FOOTAGE HELPED TRACE HER FINAL MOVEMENTS
A heartbreaking development has emerged in the s…

Exclusive | Feds smash wild train robbery crime ring accused of pillaging over $20M in daring heists

Federal agents have crushed a train robbery ring charged with stealing more than $22 million in Nike sneakers, Milwaukee tools and other hot goods after coordinating the thefts on Instagram.

Homeland…

JADE LANGTON WAS JUST 23 — HER LIFE WAS CUT SHORT IN A FATAL BMW POLICE PURSUIT 𝔠r𝘢sh THAT ALSO KI//ED A 22-YEAR-OLD MAN

JADE LANGTON WAS JUST 23 — HER LIFE WAS CUT SHORT IN A FATAL BMW POLICE PURSUIT 𝔠r𝘢sh THAT ALSO KILLED A 22-YEAR-OLD MAN
LEEDS, ENGLAND — November 18, 2026
She was just 23 years old, with so much of l…

Second California teen accuses rapist therapist of 𝘴єxual 𝘢bu𝘴e, details twisted plot to keep him quiet: attorney

A second teenage boy has claimed a California therapist sexually abused him while he was under her care and blackmailed him into staying silent.

Sofia Drotts, 26, a behavioral health clinician at Con…

20-YEAR-OLD ILLINOIS BUSINESS OWNER diᩚєs IN JAMAICA AFTER TRYING TO SAVE HIS MOTHER FROM WATERFALL

20-YEAR-OLD ILLINOIS BUSINESS OWNER diᩚєs IN JAMAICA AFTER TRYING TO SAVE HIS MOTHER FROM WATERFALL
A 20-year-old businessman from Illinois has died during a family vacation in Jamaica after reportedly…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *